Select Page

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Hinton v Stobinski: Director Misfeasance and Litigation Funding

The recent High Court decision in Hinton v Stobinski (Re St Mark Lions Ltd) [2026] EWHC 2386 (Ch) provides useful guidance on the circumstances in which a liquidator can use section 212 of the Insolvency Act 1986 to pursue claims against a director.

The case concerned an application by the liquidator of St Mark Lions Ltd against the company’s sole director and shareholder, Dr Marek Stobinski. Among the claims was the recovery of an overdrawn director’s loan account, alongside allegations concerning payments made from the company’s bank account and breaches of the director’s duties under the Companies Act 2006.

While the liquidator was ultimately successful, the judgment highlights an important distinction between a straightforward contractual debt and liability arising from a director’s breach of duty.

If you’d like to skip straight to the funding options for insolvency claims, please click here.

The director’s loan account dispute

The liquidator sought recovery of more than £214,000. This included approximately £112,500 attributed to an overdrawn director’s loan account, along with other payments which the liquidator alleged had been made without proper justification.

The claims were brought using the statutory procedure under section 212 of the Insolvency Act 1986 and an application under rule 1.35 of the Insolvency (England and Wales) Rules 2016.

Section 212 provides a mechanism through which a liquidator can ask the court to examine the conduct of an officer where there has been misapplication or retention of company property, misfeasance, or a breach of fiduciary or other duty in relation to the company.

The difficulty was whether that mechanism could also be used to recover an ordinary debt owed by a director to the company.

A simple debt is not enough

Deputy ICC Judge Curl KC considered the historical authorities, including Re ETIC Ltd, and examined the development of the wording of section 212. Although the modern provision refers to a breach of “any other duty in relation to the company”, the court concluded that this did not extend to a straightforward contractual obligation to repay a loan.

A simple loan creates a contractual right for the company to receive repayment. It does not, without more, amount to the type of wrongdoing or misconduct contemplated by section 212. The director’s obligation to repay the loan arises from the loan agreement rather than from their position as a director.

This distinction is important for liquidators considering how a claim should be brought. A straightforward debt claim remains a claim belonging to the company and cannot simply be converted into a section 212 claim because the debtor happens to be a director.

Breach of duty can change the position

The judgment does, however, make clear that the existence of a director’s loan account does not prevent section 212 from being relevant.

The circumstances surrounding the loan may give rise to separate breaches of the director’s duties. For example, there could be issues concerning whether the loan was properly authorised, whether the director acted in the interests of the company, whether company assets were being used improperly, or whether the director continued to extract funds when the company’s financial position meant that creditor interests had to be taken into account.

In those circumstances, the liability is no longer simply a matter of recovering a contractual debt. The same facts may establish misfeasance or breach of fiduciary or other duties by the director.

That distinction proved decisive in Hinton v Stobinski. 

The liquidator ultimately succeeded

Although the court rejected the argument that the director’s loan account could be recovered as a straightforward debt through section 212, this did not prevent the liquidator from recovering the relevant sum.

The court found that Dr Stobinski had breached his duties under sections 172 and 175 of the Companies Act 2006 and his common law duty of care under section 174. In particular, once the company was approaching insolvency, he should have stopped drawing on the loan account and taken steps to recover the company’s asset represented by the debt.

The court therefore concluded that he was liable to compensate the company in an amount corresponding to the director’s loan account balance.

This demonstrates why the factual circumstances surrounding a director’s conduct can be just as important as the accounting balance itself.

Procedural considerations for insolvency claims

The case also provides a wider procedural warning. The liquidator had brought the proceedings using an application rather than commencing a conventional Part 7 claim. The respondent argued that the debt claim was improperly brought and was incapable of being cured.

The judge considered previous authorities including Manolete Partners plc v Hayward and Barrett Holdings Ltd and Re Taunton Logs Ltd. In those cases, procedural defects had been capable of rectification.

Although the judge concluded that the section 212 route was not available for the straightforward debt claim, he did not consider the proceedings to be a nullity. Had it been necessary, he indicated that the proceedings could have been rectified.

For liquidators, this reinforces the importance of identifying the legal basis for a proposed recovery claim at an early stage and ensuring that the correct procedural route is followed.

What does the decision mean for insolvency litigation?

Hinton v Stobinski is particularly relevant where an insolvent company has potential claims against directors or other connected parties. A director’s loan account may appear to present a relatively straightforward recovery opportunity. However, the legal analysis may be more complicated where the director’s conduct surrounding the account raises questions about breaches of duty, creditor interests or the misuse of company assets.

For office holders, the decision therefore reinforces the importance of investigating not just what is owed, but how the liability arose and what the director did in relation to it. That distinction can affect both the cause of action and the appropriate procedure for pursuing recovery.

For creditors and insolvency practitioners, it also demonstrates the potential value of properly investigating director conduct before deciding whether litigation is commercially worthwhile. Where a company has insufficient resources to investigate or pursue a potential claim, insolvency litigation may provide an option for pursuing meritorious claims without placing further pressure on the insolvent estate.

Litigation funding for commercial disputes

Potential claims against directors, former directors and other connected parties can represent a valuable asset of an insolvent estate. However, identifying a viable claim is only the first step. The cost of investigation, obtaining evidence, instructing solicitors and counsel, and ultimately pursuing litigation can present a significant obstacle where the company has limited funds.

Insolvency litigation funding can provide a way for an office holder to pursue a claim without requiring the insolvent estate to meet all of those costs from its existing resources.

If you are pursuing insolvency litigation, legal costs can escalate quickly. Therefore, it is essential that you are aware of the funding options that are available to you. IPs should fully explore their options to help them meet their obligations under the Insolvency Act 1986. Listed below are some of the cost-effective options for funding insolvency litigation.

  • Assignment of claims – In some instances, it may be in the best interests of the office holder to choose to Assign or transfer claims to other parties.There are a number of firms in the market that will take Assignment over insolvency disputes. They will usually pay an upfront consideration, plus a share of recoveries after costs are deducted, although other structures are available, uncluding outright purchase.
  • Conditional fee agreements – Conditional fee agreements (CFAs), also known as ‘no win, no fee agreements’, are a type of funding arrangement that allows an IP to pursue a claim without paying legal fees upfront. Under a no win no fee basis, the law firm agrees to take on the case and only charges a fee if the case is successful. If the case is unsuccessful, the IP does not have to pay these legal fees. 
  • Contingency fee agreement – Some insolvency litigation solicitors may offer to take on an insolvency dispute claim on a contingency fee basis, which means that they will only charge a fee if they are successful in securing a financial settlement or damages. The fee payable to the solicitor is usually a percentage of the amount recovered, and if the case is unsuccessful, the law firm will not charge a fee.
  • Third party litigation funding – In some cases, third party litigation funders may be willing to provide funding for an insolvency dispute claim in exchange for a percentage of any financial settlement or damages awarded. This option can be attractive for individuals who cannot afford to pay for legal fees themselves but have a strong case. ATE insurance is often used in conjunction with this type of funding.
  • After the event insurance – After the event (ATE) insurance is a type of insurance that can provide cover for legal costs in the event that a case is unsuccessful. This option can be particularly useful in cases where the outcome is uncertain, and the costs of losing a case could be significant. ATE insurance is often used alongside conditional fee agreements and contingency fee agreements. ATE can also be used to meet some expenses, such as court fees, in a cost-effective manner (as an alternative to funding or assignment).

    How Annecto Legal can assist

    For insolvency practitioners, selecting the right funding solution is often just as important as identifying the legal merits of a claim. At Annecto Legal, we work with a broad network of insurers, litigation funders and claim purchasers to help practitioners fulfil their statutory duties while protecting insolvency estates from unnecessary financial risk.

    Our team provides independent written reports comparing available insolvency litigation funding options, enabling practitioners to demonstrate that appropriate consideration has been given to funding and risk management.

    Whether you are investigating an insolvency claim, pursuing asset recovery proceedings or defending insolvency litigation, Annecto Legal can help you identify the most suitable funding solution and maximise the prospects of a successful outcome.

    Get in touch

    * Annecto Legal can only assist on case where the loss is in excess of £100,000, with the exception of data breach claims. If you need assistance on a claim worth over £100,000, please get in touch using our form or the details below:

    Registered Office

    Annecto Legal Ltd, 106 Kennedy Building, Murray Street, Manchester , M4 6HS

    London Office

    4th Floor Silverstream House, 45 Fitzroy Street, Fitzrovia, London,

    W1T 6EB

    Phone

    0800 612 6587

    Email

    info@annectolegal.co.uk

    Get help for your case

    Annecto Legal do not provide legal advice.  We can pass your enquiry onto a firm of solicitors with experience in your type of claim,  who we work with, and may be able to assist. If you would like us to do this, please complete the form below. Please note, we do not receive payments from the firms on our panel, they are independent law firms and we are not recommending use of this firm, we simply pass your enquiry onto a firm who may be able to help. If you choose to start your claim using one of these firms, Annecto Legal will not be dealing with the claim; however, we may provide litigation funding or insurance for your case, if required.  You should make your own enquiries as to whether the firm of solicitors is suitable to carry out legal work on your behalf.

    Value

    Consent